Discussion:
can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
S***@aerofire.com
2015-12-22 16:14:34 UTC
Permalink
Hi All,

I can't check the forum archives right now because the website isn't loading for me for some reason. Based on NFPA 13 2013.

Can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?

Assuming we meet the all the minimum/maximum spacing requirements, vertical distance below the deck requirements, standard spray sprinklers, ordinary hazard occupancy, noncombustible construction. Walking from branchline to branchline left to right, can I install upright, upright, sidewall facing right, sidewall facing left, upright, upright. With spacing from upright to upright equal to 12ft, spacing from upright to backside of sidewall of 6ft, and spacing from sidewall face to sidewall face equal to 20ft. Is this acceptable?

The first thing most people say is "will the sidewall be next to something like a baffle or installed with the pipe in a soffit?" As of now, no, there is nothing behind the sidewalls. If something is required, please help me find the direction in the code for this requirement and design parameters. Because right now all I am finding is a lot of "grey" area that people can interpret whichever way suits their needs. I'm looking for "black and white" if it is in there. If it's only "grey", opinions are greatly appreciated.

Thank you for your time and help!

Thanks,
Sean VG
Richard Carr
2015-12-22 16:18:51 UTC
Permalink
Under overhead doors is only place I know is acceptable without a wall.



Sent from my T-Mobile 4G LTE Device


-------- Original message --------
From: ***@aerofire.com
Date: 12/22/2015 11:14 AM (GMT-05:00)
To: ***@lists.firesprinkler.org
Subject: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?

Hi All,

I can't check the forum archives right now because the website isn't loading for me for some reason. Based on NFPA 13 2013.

Can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?

Assuming we meet the all the minimum/maximum spacing requirements, vertical distance below the deck requirements, standard spray sprinklers, ordinary hazard occupancy, noncombustible construction. Walking from branchline to branchline left to right, can I install upright, upright, sidewall facing right, sidewall facing left, upright, upright. With spacing from upright to upright equal to 12ft, spacing from upright to backside of sidewall of 6ft, and spacing from sidewall face to sidewall face equal to 20ft. Is this acceptable?

The first thing most people say is "will the sidewall be next to something like a baffle or installed with the pipe in a soffit?" As of now, no, there is nothing behind the sidewalls. If something is required, please help me find the direction in the code for this requirement and design parameters. Because right now all I am finding is a lot of "grey" area that people can interpret whichever way suits their needs. I'm looking for "black and white" if it is in there. If it's only "grey", opinions are greatly appreciated.

Thank you for your time and help!

Thanks,
Sean VG
Brad Casterline
2015-12-22 16:58:08 UTC
Permalink
Sean, I found this in the archives:
*****
Can a horizontal sidewall sprinkler be installed in the center of a room
(flat, smooth clg) provided sprinkler coverage is added behind the
sidewall? In other words, not installed near a wall or soffit.

In reality a sidewall installed 4" to 6" below the ceiling (away from a
wall/soffit) should activate in similar fashion as exposed pendents and
uprights (1" - 12" below clg). If code permits "exposed" sidewalls to
be installed below roll up doors without soffits, can't an "exposed"
sidewall be installed elsewhere?

Is there anything in the listing of a sidewall that requires the
sprinkler be installed on a wall or soffit? Are there any ROP/ROC
responses from the committee that would help answer the question?

Thoughts?

Duane Johnson, PE
Program Manager
Division of the Fire Marshal (Support Contractor)
Office of Research Services
National Institutes of Health
301-496-0487


Duane,

NFPA 13(2007) 8.7.4.1.2 addresses the location of vertical and
horizontal sidewalls in relation to the wall that they are projected
from.

Sidewall sprinklers cannot be positioned in the center of a room as a
pendant.



Dale F. Wingard, SET
Design Manager
Triple "A" Fire Protection, Inc.
251.649.2034
***@aaafp.com


********
Brad


-----Original Message-----
From: Sprinklerforum [mailto:sprinklerforum-***@lists.firesprinkler.org]
On Behalf Of Richard Carr
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 10:19 AM
To: ***@lists.firesprinkler.org
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?

Under overhead doors is only place I know is acceptable without a wall.



Sent from my T-Mobile 4G LTE Device


-------- Original message --------
From: ***@aerofire.com
Date: 12/22/2015 11:14 AM (GMT-05:00)
To: ***@lists.firesprinkler.org
Subject: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?

Hi All,

I can't check the forum archives right now because the website isn't loading
for me for some reason. Based on NFPA 13 2013.

Can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?

Assuming we meet the all the minimum/maximum spacing requirements, vertical
distance below the deck requirements, standard spray sprinklers, ordinary
hazard occupancy, noncombustible construction. Walking from branchline to
branchline left to right, can I install upright, upright, sidewall facing
right, sidewall facing left, upright, upright. With spacing from upright to
upright equal to 12ft, spacing from upright to backside of sidewall of 6ft,
and spacing from sidewall face to sidewall face equal to 20ft. Is this
acceptable?

The first thing most people say is "will the sidewall be next to something
like a baffle or installed with the pipe in a soffit?" As of now, no, there
is nothing behind the sidewalls. If something is required, please help me
find the direction in the code for this requirement and design parameters.
Because right now all I am finding is a lot of "grey" area that people can
interpret whichever way suits their needs. I'm looking for "black and
white" if it is in there. If it's only "grey", opinions are greatly
appreciated.

Thank you for your time and help!

Thanks,
Sean VG





_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
***@lists.firesprinkler.org
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
S***@aerofire.com
2015-12-22 17:54:03 UTC
Permalink
Thank you Richard and Brad.

These are some of the exact points I was looking at/for. Up to this point we had only used them under garage doors. But like Duane brought up, we were wondering if they can be installed under garage doors and be expected to operate, then shouldn't they also be allowed to be installed in "exposed" scenarios. Maybe this just one of those "calculated risks" by the committee if no other testing has been done.

Moving on, so if I follow 8.7.4.1.2.2, and located the deflector accordingly off the "wall". What are the other defining characteristics of this "wall"? How deep is it? How long does it have to be? As far as I know "wall" isn't defined in Chapter 3. You may laugh and think I am going too far with this, but one of the major sprinkler manufactures states the following in one of their product listings "Horizontal sidewall sprinklers are designed for installation along a wall or the side of a beam". Since they are clearly indicating beams are acceptable for proper operation, can I assume "wall" in 8.7.4.1.2.2 doesn't mean it has to run from floor to ceiling. From this point going forward I can see someone arguing from (6) different routes, some of which could be considered "educated guesses". First (2) should be completely acceptable but not preferred, Next (3) have their pros/cons and varying degrees of applicability, last (1) is the most preferred but probably won't be
accepted.

(1) Build a wall.
(2) Install a beam.
(3) Use the definition of Compartment from 3.3.6. A sidewall can be installed in a "compartment", so an 8" lintel should be sufficient. Since the 8" lintel allows a maximum opening of 8ft in the wall, space the heads every 8ft and run the lintel the length of the sidewalls.
(4) Use the definition of Draft Curtain from 8.4.6.4.1. Since this is acceptable to separate sprinklers with different response times, it will clearly delay the heat travel long enough for a sprinkler to operate. This would require a barrier 2ft deep running the length of the sprinklers. No apparent restriction on sprinkler spacing.
(5) Use the definition of Draft Stop from 8.15.4.2. Since this is acceptable to delay heat traveling vertically from floor to floor. This would require a barrier 18in deep with heads spaced 6ft apart.
(6) If we decide the wall/beam isn't required to be a heat trap, but rather a protection of spray from other sprinklers. Use the definition for Baffles with Sidewalls 8.7.3.4. Baffles are at least 8" long, 6" high, be between 2in and 3in above the deflector, and the bottom be at least even with the deflector.

Obviously I would like to choose (6) if acceptable. However do you see any viability of these (4) "educated guesses"?

I appreciate any further input/opinion and of course your time to listen to me ramble on.

Thanks,
Sean VG



-----Original Message-----
From: Sprinklerforum [mailto:sprinklerforum-***@lists.firesprinkler.org] On Behalf Of Brad Casterline
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 9:58 AM
To: ***@lists.firesprinkler.org
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?

Sean, I found this in the archives:
*****
Can a horizontal sidewall sprinkler be installed in the center of a room (flat, smooth clg) provided sprinkler coverage is added behind the sidewall? In other words, not installed near a wall or soffit.

In reality a sidewall installed 4" to 6" below the ceiling (away from a
wall/soffit) should activate in similar fashion as exposed pendents and uprights (1" - 12" below clg). If code permits "exposed" sidewalls to be installed below roll up doors without soffits, can't an "exposed"
sidewall be installed elsewhere?

Is there anything in the listing of a sidewall that requires the sprinkler be installed on a wall or soffit? Are there any ROP/ROC responses from the committee that would help answer the question?

Thoughts?

Duane Johnson, PE
Program Manager
Division of the Fire Marshal (Support Contractor) Office of Research Services National Institutes of Health
301-496-0487


Duane,

NFPA 13(2007) 8.7.4.1.2 addresses the location of vertical and horizontal sidewalls in relation to the wall that they are projected from.

Sidewall sprinklers cannot be positioned in the center of a room as a pendant.



Dale F. Wingard, SET
Design Manager
Triple "A" Fire Protection, Inc.
251.649.2034
***@aaafp.com


********
Brad


-----Original Message-----
From: Sprinklerforum [mailto:sprinklerforum-***@lists.firesprinkler.org]
On Behalf Of Richard Carr
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 10:19 AM
To: ***@lists.firesprinkler.org
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?

Under overhead doors is only place I know is acceptable without a wall.



Sent from my T-Mobile 4G LTE Device


-------- Original message --------
From: ***@aerofire.com
Date: 12/22/2015 11:14 AM (GMT-05:00)
To: ***@lists.firesprinkler.org
Subject: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?

Hi All,

I can't check the forum archives right now because the website isn't loading for me for some reason. Based on NFPA 13 2013.

Can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?

Assuming we meet the all the minimum/maximum spacing requirements, vertical distance below the deck requirements, standard spray sprinklers, ordinary hazard occupancy, noncombustible construction. Walking from branchline to branchline left to right, can I install upright, upright, sidewall facing right, sidewall facing left, upright, upright. With spacing from upright to upright equal to 12ft, spacing from upright to backside of sidewall of 6ft, and spacing from sidewall face to sidewall face equal to 20ft. Is this acceptable?

The first thing most people say is "will the sidewall be next to something like a baffle or installed with the pipe in a soffit?" As of now, no, there is nothing behind the sidewalls. If something is required, please help me find the direction in the code for this requirement and design parameters.
Because right now all I am finding is a lot of "grey" area that people can interpret whichever way suits their needs. I'm looking for "black and white" if it is in there. If it's only "grey", opinions are greatly appreciated.

Thank you for your time and help!

Thanks,
Sean VG





_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
***@lists.firesprinkler.org
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
***@lists.firesprinkler.org
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Brad Casterline
2015-12-22 22:48:53 UTC
Permalink
No better subject to ramble on about than sprinkler activation.
I think citing sidewalls under an overhead door is misplaced though because
in that case there is an 'above AND below' setup, and whether the door is
up or down the fire has to be pretty much right under the 'exposed
sidewall'. Not so with one compliment.
If you did the back-to-back sidewalls in the middle of the space I would
advocate no wall, baffle, or beam, that being based on some primitive,
course modeling I did several years ago looking at activation times for
water curtains with and without a draft stop: with seemed to 1) slow the
velocity of the ceiling jet a tad and 2) block half the pattern-- RTI is
based on temp AND velocity.

I've been modeling this all afternoon in my mind because I skated a little
early today-
I'll actually do it I'm sure, soon, make a youtube movie, and post the link
to that here-- but, you should resign yourself, re. any real life
application to using a sideWALL essentially with a 'wall' :) ;) :)

B-rad
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Thank you Richard and Brad.
These are some of the exact points I was looking at/for. Up to this point
we had only used them under garage doors. But like Duane brought up, we
were wondering if they can be installed under garage doors and be expected
to operate, then shouldn't they also be allowed to be installed in
"exposed" scenarios. Maybe this just one of those "calculated risks" by
the committee if no other testing has been done.
Moving on, so if I follow 8.7.4.1.2.2, and located the deflector
accordingly off the "wall". What are the other defining characteristics of
this "wall"? How deep is it? How long does it have to be? As far as I
know "wall" isn't defined in Chapter 3. You may laugh and think I am going
too far with this, but one of the major sprinkler manufactures states the
following in one of their product listings "Horizontal sidewall sprinklers
are designed for installation along a wall or the side of a beam". Since
they are clearly indicating beams are acceptable for proper operation, can
I assume "wall" in 8.7.4.1.2.2 doesn't mean it has to run from floor to
ceiling. From this point going forward I can see someone arguing from (6)
different routes, some of which could be considered "educated guesses".
First (2) should be completely acceptable but not preferred, Next (3) have
their pros/cons and varying degrees of applicability, last (1) is the most
preferred but probably won't be
accepted.
(1) Build a wall.
(2) Install a beam.
(3) Use the definition of Compartment from 3.3.6. A sidewall can be
installed in a "compartment", so an 8" lintel should be sufficient. Since
the 8" lintel allows a maximum opening of 8ft in the wall, space the heads
every 8ft and run the lintel the length of the sidewalls.
(4) Use the definition of Draft Curtain from 8.4.6.4.1. Since this is
acceptable to separate sprinklers with different response times, it will
clearly delay the heat travel long enough for a sprinkler to operate. This
would require a barrier 2ft deep running the length of the sprinklers. No
apparent restriction on sprinkler spacing.
(5) Use the definition of Draft Stop from 8.15.4.2. Since this is
acceptable to delay heat traveling vertically from floor to floor. This
would require a barrier 18in deep with heads spaced 6ft apart.
(6) If we decide the wall/beam isn't required to be a heat trap, but
rather a protection of spray from other sprinklers. Use the definition for
Baffles with Sidewalls 8.7.3.4. Baffles are at least 8" long, 6" high, be
between 2in and 3in above the deflector, and the bottom be at least even
with the deflector.
Obviously I would like to choose (6) if acceptable. However do you see
any viability of these (4) "educated guesses"?
I appreciate any further input/opinion and of course your time to listen to me ramble on.
Thanks,
Sean VG
-----Original Message-----
Casterline
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 9:58 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
*****
Can a horizontal sidewall sprinkler be installed in the center of a room
(flat, smooth clg) provided sprinkler coverage is added behind the
sidewall? In other words, not installed near a wall or soffit.
In reality a sidewall installed 4" to 6" below the ceiling (away from a
wall/soffit) should activate in similar fashion as exposed pendents and
uprights (1" - 12" below clg). If code permits "exposed" sidewalls to be
installed below roll up doors without soffits, can't an "exposed"
sidewall be installed elsewhere?
Is there anything in the listing of a sidewall that requires the sprinkler
be installed on a wall or soffit? Are there any ROP/ROC responses from the
committee that would help answer the question?
Thoughts?
Duane Johnson, PE
Program Manager
Division of the Fire Marshal (Support Contractor) Office of Research
Services National Institutes of Health
301-496-0487
Duane,
NFPA 13(2007) 8.7.4.1.2 addresses the location of vertical and horizontal
sidewalls in relation to the wall that they are projected from.
Sidewall sprinklers cannot be positioned in the center of a room as a pendant.
Dale F. Wingard, SET
Design Manager
Triple "A" Fire Protection, Inc.
251.649.2034
********
Brad
-----Original Message-----
On Behalf Of Richard Carr
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 10:19 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
Under overhead doors is only place I know is acceptable without a wall.
Sent from my T-Mobile 4G LTE Device
-------- Original message --------
Date: 12/22/2015 11:14 AM (GMT-05:00)
Subject: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
Hi All,
I can't check the forum archives right now because the website isn't
loading for me for some reason. Based on NFPA 13 2013.
Can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
Assuming we meet the all the minimum/maximum spacing requirements,
vertical distance below the deck requirements, standard spray sprinklers,
ordinary hazard occupancy, noncombustible construction. Walking from
branchline to branchline left to right, can I install upright, upright,
sidewall facing right, sidewall facing left, upright, upright. With
spacing from upright to upright equal to 12ft, spacing from upright to
backside of sidewall of 6ft, and spacing from sidewall face to sidewall
face equal to 20ft. Is this acceptable?
The first thing most people say is "will the sidewall be next to something
like a baffle or installed with the pipe in a soffit?" As of now, no,
there is nothing behind the sidewalls. If something is required, please
help me find the direction in the code for this requirement and design
parameters.
Because right now all I am finding is a lot of "grey" area that people can
interpret whichever way suits their needs. I'm looking for "black and
white" if it is in there. If it's only "grey", opinions are greatly
appreciated.
Thank you for your time and help!
Thanks,
Sean VG
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Brad Casterline
2015-12-22 23:05:29 UTC
Permalink
*coarse. And an 18" deep draft stop is for containing smoke, not to enhance
sprinkler activation, and, I apologise for not knowing how to trim threads
when at home using my phone.
Post by Brad Casterline
No better subject to ramble on about than sprinkler activation.
I think citing sidewalls under an overhead door is misplaced though
because in that case there is an 'above AND below' setup, and whether the
door is up or down the fire has to be pretty much right under the 'exposed
sidewall'. Not so with one compliment.
If you did the back-to-back sidewalls in the middle of the space I would
advocate no wall, baffle, or beam, that being based on some primitive,
course modeling I did several years ago looking at activation times for
water curtains with and without a draft stop: with seemed to 1) slow the
velocity of the ceiling jet a tad and 2) block half the pattern-- RTI is
based on temp AND velocity.
I've been modeling this all afternoon in my mind because I skated a little
early today-
I'll actually do it I'm sure, soon, make a youtube movie, and post the
link to that here-- but, you should resign yourself, re. any real life
application to using a sideWALL essentially with a 'wall' :) ;) :)
B-rad
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Thank you Richard and Brad.
These are some of the exact points I was looking at/for. Up to this
point we had only used them under garage doors. But like Duane brought up,
we were wondering if they can be installed under garage doors and be
expected to operate, then shouldn't they also be allowed to be installed in
"exposed" scenarios. Maybe this just one of those "calculated risks" by
the committee if no other testing has been done.
Moving on, so if I follow 8.7.4.1.2.2, and located the deflector
accordingly off the "wall". What are the other defining characteristics of
this "wall"? How deep is it? How long does it have to be? As far as I
know "wall" isn't defined in Chapter 3. You may laugh and think I am going
too far with this, but one of the major sprinkler manufactures states the
following in one of their product listings "Horizontal sidewall sprinklers
are designed for installation along a wall or the side of a beam". Since
they are clearly indicating beams are acceptable for proper operation, can
I assume "wall" in 8.7.4.1.2.2 doesn't mean it has to run from floor to
ceiling. From this point going forward I can see someone arguing from (6)
different routes, some of which could be considered "educated guesses".
First (2) should be completely acceptable but not preferred, Next (3) have
their pros/cons and varying degrees of applicability, last (1) is the most
preferred but probably won't be
accepted.
(1) Build a wall.
(2) Install a beam.
(3) Use the definition of Compartment from 3.3.6. A sidewall can be
installed in a "compartment", so an 8" lintel should be sufficient. Since
the 8" lintel allows a maximum opening of 8ft in the wall, space the heads
every 8ft and run the lintel the length of the sidewalls.
(4) Use the definition of Draft Curtain from 8.4.6.4.1. Since this is
acceptable to separate sprinklers with different response times, it will
clearly delay the heat travel long enough for a sprinkler to operate. This
would require a barrier 2ft deep running the length of the sprinklers. No
apparent restriction on sprinkler spacing.
(5) Use the definition of Draft Stop from 8.15.4.2. Since this is
acceptable to delay heat traveling vertically from floor to floor. This
would require a barrier 18in deep with heads spaced 6ft apart.
(6) If we decide the wall/beam isn't required to be a heat trap, but
rather a protection of spray from other sprinklers. Use the definition for
Baffles with Sidewalls 8.7.3.4. Baffles are at least 8" long, 6" high, be
between 2in and 3in above the deflector, and the bottom be at least even
with the deflector.
Obviously I would like to choose (6) if acceptable. However do you see
any viability of these (4) "educated guesses"?
I appreciate any further input/opinion and of course your time to listen to me ramble on.
Thanks,
Sean VG
-----Original Message-----
Casterline
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 9:58 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
*****
Can a horizontal sidewall sprinkler be installed in the center of a room
(flat, smooth clg) provided sprinkler coverage is added behind the
sidewall? In other words, not installed near a wall or soffit.
In reality a sidewall installed 4" to 6" below the ceiling (away from a
wall/soffit) should activate in similar fashion as exposed pendents and
uprights (1" - 12" below clg). If code permits "exposed" sidewalls to be
installed below roll up doors without soffits, can't an "exposed"
sidewall be installed elsewhere?
Is there anything in the listing of a sidewall that requires the
sprinkler be installed on a wall or soffit? Are there any ROP/ROC
responses from the committee that would help answer the question?
Thoughts?
Duane Johnson, PE
Program Manager
Division of the Fire Marshal (Support Contractor) Office of Research
Services National Institutes of Health
301-496-0487
Duane,
NFPA 13(2007) 8.7.4.1.2 addresses the location of vertical and horizontal
sidewalls in relation to the wall that they are projected from.
Sidewall sprinklers cannot be positioned in the center of a room as a pendant.
Dale F. Wingard, SET
Design Manager
Triple "A" Fire Protection, Inc.
251.649.2034
********
Brad
-----Original Message-----
On Behalf Of Richard Carr
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 10:19 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
Under overhead doors is only place I know is acceptable without a wall.
Sent from my T-Mobile 4G LTE Device
-------- Original message --------
Date: 12/22/2015 11:14 AM (GMT-05:00)
Subject: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
Hi All,
I can't check the forum archives right now because the website isn't
loading for me for some reason. Based on NFPA 13 2013.
Can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
Assuming we meet the all the minimum/maximum spacing requirements,
vertical distance below the deck requirements, standard spray sprinklers,
ordinary hazard occupancy, noncombustible construction. Walking from
branchline to branchline left to right, can I install upright, upright,
sidewall facing right, sidewall facing left, upright, upright. With
spacing from upright to upright equal to 12ft, spacing from upright to
backside of sidewall of 6ft, and spacing from sidewall face to sidewall
face equal to 20ft. Is this acceptable?
The first thing most people say is "will the sidewall be next to
something like a baffle or installed with the pipe in a soffit?" As of
now, no, there is nothing behind the sidewalls. If something is required,
please help me find the direction in the code for this requirement and
design parameters.
Because right now all I am finding is a lot of "grey" area that people
can interpret whichever way suits their needs. I'm looking for "black and
white" if it is in there. If it's only "grey", opinions are greatly
appreciated.
Thank you for your time and help!
Thanks,
Sean VG
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Brad Casterline
2015-12-24 01:42:44 UTC
Permalink
A few more things Sean then I'll be able to sleep-
1) you're welcome
2) you have put a lot of good thought into this, and thank you for
prompting the ponderance
3) distinct sidewalls back-to-back in the middle of a space without a
baffle or beam to prevent cold soldering is a no go I realize now, but with
a baffle or beam the head on the opposite side of the ignition point might
not activate due to the way the ceiling jet hits the beam, goes under it,
and comes back up the other side-- the opposite side spinkler, being above
the bottom and close to the side of the beam leaves it in a "slow and cold
pocket".
The best thing would be a Tyco type back to back attic head, (2 sidewalls
with one element) but they would have to bend both deflectors up to work
with a flat ceiling :) unless the ceiling height was up there a ways.
4) seems like you guys there at Aero are really on the ball!!!-- prime
candidates for some serious fire modeling. . .

wbr, Brad
Post by Brad Casterline
*coarse. And an 18" deep draft stop is for containing smoke, not to
enhance sprinkler activation, and, I apologise for not knowing how to trim
threads when at home using my phone.
Post by Brad Casterline
No better subject to ramble on about than sprinkler activation.
I think citing sidewalls under an overhead door is misplaced though
because in that case there is an 'above AND below' setup, and whether the
door is up or down the fire has to be pretty much right under the 'exposed
sidewall'. Not so with one compliment.
If you did the back-to-back sidewalls in the middle of the space I would
advocate no wall, baffle, or beam, that being based on some primitive,
course modeling I did several years ago looking at activation times for
water curtains with and without a draft stop: with seemed to 1) slow the
velocity of the ceiling jet a tad and 2) block half the pattern-- RTI is
based on temp AND velocity.
I've been modeling this all afternoon in my mind because I skated a
little early today-
I'll actually do it I'm sure, soon, make a youtube movie, and post the
link to that here-- but, you should resign yourself, re. any real life
application to using a sideWALL essentially with a 'wall' :) ;) :)
B-rad
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Thank you Richard and Brad.
These are some of the exact points I was looking at/for. Up to this
point we had only used them under garage doors. But like Duane brought up,
we were wondering if they can be installed under garage doors and be
expected to operate, then shouldn't they also be allowed to be installed in
"exposed" scenarios. Maybe this just one of those "calculated risks" by
the committee if no other testing has been done.
Moving on, so if I follow 8.7.4.1.2.2, and located the deflector
accordingly off the "wall". What are the other defining characteristics of
this "wall"? How deep is it? How long does it have to be? As far as I
know "wall" isn't defined in Chapter 3. You may laugh and think I am going
too far with this, but one of the major sprinkler manufactures states the
following in one of their product listings "Horizontal sidewall sprinklers
are designed for installation along a wall or the side of a beam". Since
they are clearly indicating beams are acceptable for proper operation, can
I assume "wall" in 8.7.4.1.2.2 doesn't mean it has to run from floor to
ceiling. From this point going forward I can see someone arguing from (6)
different routes, some of which could be considered "educated guesses".
First (2) should be completely acceptable but not preferred, Next (3) have
their pros/cons and varying degrees of applicability, last (1) is the most
preferred but probably won't be
accepted.
(1) Build a wall.
(2) Install a beam.
(3) Use the definition of Compartment from 3.3.6. A sidewall can be
installed in a "compartment", so an 8" lintel should be sufficient. Since
the 8" lintel allows a maximum opening of 8ft in the wall, space the heads
every 8ft and run the lintel the length of the sidewalls.
(4) Use the definition of Draft Curtain from 8.4.6.4.1. Since this is
acceptable to separate sprinklers with different response times, it will
clearly delay the heat travel long enough for a sprinkler to operate. This
would require a barrier 2ft deep running the length of the sprinklers. No
apparent restriction on sprinkler spacing.
(5) Use the definition of Draft Stop from 8.15.4.2. Since this is
acceptable to delay heat traveling vertically from floor to floor. This
would require a barrier 18in deep with heads spaced 6ft apart.
(6) If we decide the wall/beam isn't required to be a heat trap, but
rather a protection of spray from other sprinklers. Use the definition for
Baffles with Sidewalls 8.7.3.4. Baffles are at least 8" long, 6" high, be
between 2in and 3in above the deflector, and the bottom be at least even
with the deflector.
Obviously I would like to choose (6) if acceptable. However do you see
any viability of these (4) "educated guesses"?
I appreciate any further input/opinion and of course your time to listen
to me ramble on.
Thanks,
Sean VG
-----Original Message-----
Casterline
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 9:58 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
*****
Can a horizontal sidewall sprinkler be installed in the center of a room
(flat, smooth clg) provided sprinkler coverage is added behind the
sidewall? In other words, not installed near a wall or soffit.
In reality a sidewall installed 4" to 6" below the ceiling (away from a
wall/soffit) should activate in similar fashion as exposed pendents and
uprights (1" - 12" below clg). If code permits "exposed" sidewalls to be
installed below roll up doors without soffits, can't an "exposed"
sidewall be installed elsewhere?
Is there anything in the listing of a sidewall that requires the
sprinkler be installed on a wall or soffit? Are there any ROP/ROC
responses from the committee that would help answer the question?
Thoughts?
Duane Johnson, PE
Program Manager
Division of the Fire Marshal (Support Contractor) Office of Research
Services National Institutes of Health
301-496-0487
Duane,
NFPA 13(2007) 8.7.4.1.2 addresses the location of vertical and
horizontal sidewalls in relation to the wall that they are projected from.
Sidewall sprinklers cannot be positioned in the center of a room as a pendant.
Dale F. Wingard, SET
Design Manager
Triple "A" Fire Protection, Inc.
251.649.2034
********
Brad
-----Original Message-----
On Behalf Of Richard Carr
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 10:19 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
Under overhead doors is only place I know is acceptable without a wall.
Sent from my T-Mobile 4G LTE Device
-------- Original message --------
Date: 12/22/2015 11:14 AM (GMT-05:00)
Subject: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
Hi All,
I can't check the forum archives right now because the website isn't
loading for me for some reason. Based on NFPA 13 2013.
Can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
Assuming we meet the all the minimum/maximum spacing requirements,
vertical distance below the deck requirements, standard spray sprinklers,
ordinary hazard occupancy, noncombustible construction. Walking from
branchline to branchline left to right, can I install upright, upright,
sidewall facing right, sidewall facing left, upright, upright. With
spacing from upright to upright equal to 12ft, spacing from upright to
backside of sidewall of 6ft, and spacing from sidewall face to sidewall
face equal to 20ft. Is this acceptable?
The first thing most people say is "will the sidewall be next to
something like a baffle or installed with the pipe in a soffit?" As of
now, no, there is nothing behind the sidewalls. If something is required,
please help me find the direction in the code for this requirement and
design parameters.
Because right now all I am finding is a lot of "grey" area that people
can interpret whichever way suits their needs. I'm looking for "black and
white" if it is in there. If it's only "grey", opinions are greatly
appreciated.
Thank you for your time and help!
Thanks,
Sean VG
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
2015-12-25 12:11:21 UTC
Permalink
Sidewall heads without a wall is one thing, but what about sidewalls at the
bottom of elevator shafts that have a wall but no ceiling?



*Success Through Code Compliance*

*Rahe Loftin, PE *
*Regional Fire Protection Engineer*
*General Services Administration*
*Region 7 - TX, OK, NM, AR, LA*
*Facilities Management & Support 7PMC*
*c - 817-371-3102*
*o - 817-978-7299*
Post by Brad Casterline
A few more things Sean then I'll be able to sleep-
1) you're welcome
2) you have put a lot of good thought into this, and thank you for
prompting the ponderance
3) distinct sidewalls back-to-back in the middle of a space without a
baffle or beam to prevent cold soldering is a no go I realize now, but with
a baffle or beam the head on the opposite side of the ignition point might
not activate due to the way the ceiling jet hits the beam, goes under it,
and comes back up the other side-- the opposite side spinkler, being above
the bottom and close to the side of the beam leaves it in a "slow and cold
pocket".
The best thing would be a Tyco type back to back attic head, (2 sidewalls
with one element) but they would have to bend both deflectors up to work
with a flat ceiling :) unless the ceiling height was up there a ways.
4) seems like you guys there at Aero are really on the ball!!!-- prime
candidates for some serious fire modeling. . .
wbr, Brad
Post by Brad Casterline
*coarse. And an 18" deep draft stop is for containing smoke, not to
enhance sprinkler activation, and, I apologise for not knowing how to
trim
Post by Brad Casterline
threads when at home using my phone.
Post by Brad Casterline
No better subject to ramble on about than sprinkler activation.
I think citing sidewalls under an overhead door is misplaced though
because in that case there is an 'above AND below' setup, and whether
the
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
door is up or down the fire has to be pretty much right under the
'exposed
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
sidewall'. Not so with one compliment.
If you did the back-to-back sidewalls in the middle of the space I would
advocate no wall, baffle, or beam, that being based on some primitive,
course modeling I did several years ago looking at activation times for
water curtains with and without a draft stop: with seemed to 1) slow the
velocity of the ceiling jet a tad and 2) block half the pattern-- RTI is
based on temp AND velocity.
I've been modeling this all afternoon in my mind because I skated a
little early today-
I'll actually do it I'm sure, soon, make a youtube movie, and post the
link to that here-- but, you should resign yourself, re. any real life
application to using a sideWALL essentially with a 'wall' :) ;) :)
B-rad
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Thank you Richard and Brad.
These are some of the exact points I was looking at/for. Up to this
point we had only used them under garage doors. But like Duane
brought up,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
we were wondering if they can be installed under garage doors and be
expected to operate, then shouldn't they also be allowed to be
installed in
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
"exposed" scenarios. Maybe this just one of those "calculated risks"
by
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
the committee if no other testing has been done.
Moving on, so if I follow 8.7.4.1.2.2, and located the deflector
accordingly off the "wall". What are the other defining
characteristics of
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
this "wall"? How deep is it? How long does it have to be? As far as
I
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
know "wall" isn't defined in Chapter 3. You may laugh and think I am
going
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
too far with this, but one of the major sprinkler manufactures states
the
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
following in one of their product listings "Horizontal sidewall
sprinklers
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
are designed for installation along a wall or the side of a beam".
Since
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
they are clearly indicating beams are acceptable for proper operation,
can
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
I assume "wall" in 8.7.4.1.2.2 doesn't mean it has to run from floor to
ceiling. From this point going forward I can see someone arguing from
(6)
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
different routes, some of which could be considered "educated guesses".
First (2) should be completely acceptable but not preferred, Next (3)
have
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
their pros/cons and varying degrees of applicability, last (1) is the
most
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
preferred but probably won't be
accepted.
(1) Build a wall.
(2) Install a beam.
(3) Use the definition of Compartment from 3.3.6. A sidewall can be
installed in a "compartment", so an 8" lintel should be sufficient.
Since
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
the 8" lintel allows a maximum opening of 8ft in the wall, space the
heads
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
every 8ft and run the lintel the length of the sidewalls.
(4) Use the definition of Draft Curtain from 8.4.6.4.1. Since this is
acceptable to separate sprinklers with different response times, it
will
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
clearly delay the heat travel long enough for a sprinkler to operate.
This
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
would require a barrier 2ft deep running the length of the
sprinklers. No
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
apparent restriction on sprinkler spacing.
(5) Use the definition of Draft Stop from 8.15.4.2. Since this is
acceptable to delay heat traveling vertically from floor to floor.
This
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
would require a barrier 18in deep with heads spaced 6ft apart.
(6) If we decide the wall/beam isn't required to be a heat trap, but
rather a protection of spray from other sprinklers. Use the
definition for
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Baffles with Sidewalls 8.7.3.4. Baffles are at least 8" long, 6"
high, be
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
between 2in and 3in above the deflector, and the bottom be at least
even
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
with the deflector.
Obviously I would like to choose (6) if acceptable. However do you see
any viability of these (4) "educated guesses"?
I appreciate any further input/opinion and of course your time to
listen
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
to me ramble on.
Thanks,
Sean VG
-----Original Message-----
Casterline
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 9:58 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a
wall?
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
*****
Can a horizontal sidewall sprinkler be installed in the center of a
room
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
(flat, smooth clg) provided sprinkler coverage is added behind the
sidewall? In other words, not installed near a wall or soffit.
In reality a sidewall installed 4" to 6" below the ceiling (away from a
wall/soffit) should activate in similar fashion as exposed pendents and
uprights (1" - 12" below clg). If code permits "exposed" sidewalls to
be
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
installed below roll up doors without soffits, can't an "exposed"
sidewall be installed elsewhere?
Is there anything in the listing of a sidewall that requires the
sprinkler be installed on a wall or soffit? Are there any ROP/ROC
responses from the committee that would help answer the question?
Thoughts?
Duane Johnson, PE
Program Manager
Division of the Fire Marshal (Support Contractor) Office of Research
Services National Institutes of Health
301-496-0487
Duane,
NFPA 13(2007) 8.7.4.1.2 addresses the location of vertical and
horizontal sidewalls in relation to the wall that they are projected
from.
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Sidewall sprinklers cannot be positioned in the center of a room as a pendant.
Dale F. Wingard, SET
Design Manager
Triple "A" Fire Protection, Inc.
251.649.2034
********
Brad
-----Original Message-----
On Behalf Of Richard Carr
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 10:19 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a
wall?
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Under overhead doors is only place I know is acceptable without a wall.
Sent from my T-Mobile 4G LTE Device
-------- Original message --------
Date: 12/22/2015 11:14 AM (GMT-05:00)
Subject: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
Hi All,
I can't check the forum archives right now because the website isn't
loading for me for some reason. Based on NFPA 13 2013.
Can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
Assuming we meet the all the minimum/maximum spacing requirements,
vertical distance below the deck requirements, standard spray
sprinklers,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
ordinary hazard occupancy, noncombustible construction. Walking from
branchline to branchline left to right, can I install upright, upright,
sidewall facing right, sidewall facing left, upright, upright. With
spacing from upright to upright equal to 12ft, spacing from upright to
backside of sidewall of 6ft, and spacing from sidewall face to sidewall
face equal to 20ft. Is this acceptable?
The first thing most people say is "will the sidewall be next to
something like a baffle or installed with the pipe in a soffit?" As of
now, no, there is nothing behind the sidewalls. If something is
required,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
please help me find the direction in the code for this requirement and
design parameters.
Because right now all I am finding is a lot of "grey" area that people
can interpret whichever way suits their needs. I'm looking for "black
and
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
white" if it is in there. If it's only "grey", opinions are greatly
appreciated.
Thank you for your time and help!
Thanks,
Sean VG
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Charles Thurston
2015-12-25 13:37:51 UTC
Permalink
Hello Rahe,

Works good when the car is at the bottom of the shaft.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Sidewall heads without a wall is one thing, but what about sidewalls at the
bottom of elevator shafts that have a wall but no ceiling?
*Success Through Code Compliance*
*Rahe Loftin, PE *
*Regional Fire Protection Engineer*
*General Services Administration*
*Region 7 - TX, OK, NM, AR, LA*
*Facilities Management & Support 7PMC*
*c - 817-371-3102*
*o - 817-978-7299*
Post by Brad Casterline
A few more things Sean then I'll be able to sleep-
1) you're welcome
2) you have put a lot of good thought into this, and thank you for
prompting the ponderance
3) distinct sidewalls back-to-back in the middle of a space without a
baffle or beam to prevent cold soldering is a no go I realize now, but with
a baffle or beam the head on the opposite side of the ignition point might
not activate due to the way the ceiling jet hits the beam, goes under it,
and comes back up the other side-- the opposite side spinkler, being above
the bottom and close to the side of the beam leaves it in a "slow and cold
pocket".
The best thing would be a Tyco type back to back attic head, (2 sidewalls
with one element) but they would have to bend both deflectors up to work
with a flat ceiling :) unless the ceiling height was up there a ways.
4) seems like you guys there at Aero are really on the ball!!!-- prime
candidates for some serious fire modeling. . .
wbr, Brad
Post by Brad Casterline
*coarse. And an 18" deep draft stop is for containing smoke, not to
enhance sprinkler activation, and, I apologise for not knowing how to
trim
Post by Brad Casterline
threads when at home using my phone.
Post by Brad Casterline
No better subject to ramble on about than sprinkler activation.
I think citing sidewalls under an overhead door is misplaced though
because in that case there is an 'above AND below' setup, and whether
the
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
door is up or down the fire has to be pretty much right under the
'exposed
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
sidewall'. Not so with one compliment.
If you did the back-to-back sidewalls in the middle of the space I would
advocate no wall, baffle, or beam, that being based on some primitive,
course modeling I did several years ago looking at activation times for
water curtains with and without a draft stop: with seemed to 1) slow the
velocity of the ceiling jet a tad and 2) block half the pattern-- RTI is
based on temp AND velocity.
I've been modeling this all afternoon in my mind because I skated a
little early today-
I'll actually do it I'm sure, soon, make a youtube movie, and post the
link to that here-- but, you should resign yourself, re. any real life
application to using a sideWALL essentially with a 'wall' :) ;) :)
B-rad
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Thank you Richard and Brad.
These are some of the exact points I was looking at/for. Up to this
point we had only used them under garage doors. But like Duane
brought up,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
we were wondering if they can be installed under garage doors and be
expected to operate, then shouldn't they also be allowed to be
installed in
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
"exposed" scenarios. Maybe this just one of those "calculated risks"
by
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
the committee if no other testing has been done.
Moving on, so if I follow 8.7.4.1.2.2, and located the deflector
accordingly off the "wall". What are the other defining
characteristics of
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
this "wall"? How deep is it? How long does it have to be? As far as
I
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
know "wall" isn't defined in Chapter 3. You may laugh and think I am
going
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
too far with this, but one of the major sprinkler manufactures states
the
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
following in one of their product listings "Horizontal sidewall
sprinklers
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
are designed for installation along a wall or the side of a beam".
Since
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
they are clearly indicating beams are acceptable for proper operation,
can
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
I assume "wall" in 8.7.4.1.2.2 doesn't mean it has to run from floor to
ceiling. From this point going forward I can see someone arguing from
(6)
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
different routes, some of which could be considered "educated guesses".
First (2) should be completely acceptable but not preferred, Next (3)
have
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
their pros/cons and varying degrees of applicability, last (1) is the
most
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
preferred but probably won't be
accepted.
(1) Build a wall.
(2) Install a beam.
(3) Use the definition of Compartment from 3.3.6. A sidewall can be
installed in a "compartment", so an 8" lintel should be sufficient.
Since
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
the 8" lintel allows a maximum opening of 8ft in the wall, space the
heads
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
every 8ft and run the lintel the length of the sidewalls.
(4) Use the definition of Draft Curtain from 8.4.6.4.1. Since this is
acceptable to separate sprinklers with different response times, it
will
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
clearly delay the heat travel long enough for a sprinkler to operate.
This
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
would require a barrier 2ft deep running the length of the
sprinklers. No
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
apparent restriction on sprinkler spacing.
(5) Use the definition of Draft Stop from 8.15.4.2. Since this is
acceptable to delay heat traveling vertically from floor to floor.
This
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
would require a barrier 18in deep with heads spaced 6ft apart.
(6) If we decide the wall/beam isn't required to be a heat trap, but
rather a protection of spray from other sprinklers. Use the
definition for
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Baffles with Sidewalls 8.7.3.4. Baffles are at least 8" long, 6"
high, be
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
between 2in and 3in above the deflector, and the bottom be at least
even
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
with the deflector.
Obviously I would like to choose (6) if acceptable. However do you see
any viability of these (4) "educated guesses"?
I appreciate any further input/opinion and of course your time to
listen
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
to me ramble on.
Thanks,
Sean VG
-----Original Message-----
Casterline
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 9:58 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a
wall?
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
*****
Can a horizontal sidewall sprinkler be installed in the center of a
room
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
(flat, smooth clg) provided sprinkler coverage is added behind the
sidewall? In other words, not installed near a wall or soffit.
In reality a sidewall installed 4" to 6" below the ceiling (away from a
wall/soffit) should activate in similar fashion as exposed pendents and
uprights (1" - 12" below clg). If code permits "exposed" sidewalls to
be
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
installed below roll up doors without soffits, can't an "exposed"
sidewall be installed elsewhere?
Is there anything in the listing of a sidewall that requires the
sprinkler be installed on a wall or soffit? Are there any ROP/ROC
responses from the committee that would help answer the question?
Thoughts?
Duane Johnson, PE
Program Manager
Division of the Fire Marshal (Support Contractor) Office of Research
Services National Institutes of Health
301-496-0487
Duane,
NFPA 13(2007) 8.7.4.1.2 addresses the location of vertical and
horizontal sidewalls in relation to the wall that they are projected
from.
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Sidewall sprinklers cannot be positioned in the center of a room as a pendant.
Dale F. Wingard, SET
Design Manager
Triple "A" Fire Protection, Inc.
251.649.2034
********
Brad
-----Original Message-----
On Behalf Of Richard Carr
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 10:19 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a
wall?
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Under overhead doors is only place I know is acceptable without a wall.
Sent from my T-Mobile 4G LTE Device
-------- Original message --------
Date: 12/22/2015 11:14 AM (GMT-05:00)
Subject: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
Hi All,
I can't check the forum archives right now because the website isn't
loading for me for some reason. Based on NFPA 13 2013.
Can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
Assuming we meet the all the minimum/maximum spacing requirements,
vertical distance below the deck requirements, standard spray
sprinklers,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
ordinary hazard occupancy, noncombustible construction. Walking from
branchline to branchline left to right, can I install upright, upright,
sidewall facing right, sidewall facing left, upright, upright. With
spacing from upright to upright equal to 12ft, spacing from upright to
backside of sidewall of 6ft, and spacing from sidewall face to sidewall
face equal to 20ft. Is this acceptable?
The first thing most people say is "will the sidewall be next to
something like a baffle or installed with the pipe in a soffit?" As of
now, no, there is nothing behind the sidewalls. If something is
required,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
please help me find the direction in the code for this requirement and
design parameters.
Because right now all I am finding is a lot of "grey" area that people
can interpret whichever way suits their needs. I'm looking for "black
and
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
white" if it is in there. If it's only "grey", opinions are greatly
appreciated.
Thank you for your time and help!
Thanks,
Sean VG
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
--
Best regards,
Charles mailto:***@mbfsg.com
Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
2015-12-25 23:30:51 UTC
Permalink
Charles,
True if the elevator car is within 12 inches of the head but, of course,
not when it is any other position. Furthermore, what about the listing of
the sidewall head for a flat, horizontal, smooth ceiling? This certainly
does not describe the bottom of an elevator car.



*Success Through Code Compliance*

*Rahe Loftin, PE *
*Regional Fire Protection Engineer*
*General Services Administration*
*Region 7 - TX, OK, NM, AR, LA*
*Facilities Management & Support 7PMC*
*c - 817-371-3102*
*o - 817-978-7299*
Post by Charles Thurston
Hello Rahe,
Works good when the car is at the bottom of the shaft.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Sidewall heads without a wall is one thing, but what about sidewalls at
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
bottom of elevator shafts that have a wall but no ceiling?
*Success Through Code Compliance*
*Rahe Loftin, PE *
*Regional Fire Protection Engineer*
*General Services Administration*
*Region 7 - TX, OK, NM, AR, LA*
*Facilities Management & Support 7PMC*
*c - 817-371-3102*
*o - 817-978-7299*
Post by Brad Casterline
A few more things Sean then I'll be able to sleep-
1) you're welcome
2) you have put a lot of good thought into this, and thank you for
prompting the ponderance
3) distinct sidewalls back-to-back in the middle of a space without a
baffle or beam to prevent cold soldering is a no go I realize now, but
with
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
a baffle or beam the head on the opposite side of the ignition point
might
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
not activate due to the way the ceiling jet hits the beam, goes under
it,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
and comes back up the other side-- the opposite side spinkler, being
above
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
the bottom and close to the side of the beam leaves it in a "slow and
cold
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
pocket".
The best thing would be a Tyco type back to back attic head, (2
sidewalls
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
with one element) but they would have to bend both deflectors up to work
with a flat ceiling :) unless the ceiling height was up there a ways.
4) seems like you guys there at Aero are really on the ball!!!-- prime
candidates for some serious fire modeling. . .
wbr, Brad
Post by Brad Casterline
*coarse. And an 18" deep draft stop is for containing smoke, not to
enhance sprinkler activation, and, I apologise for not knowing how to
trim
Post by Brad Casterline
threads when at home using my phone.
Post by Brad Casterline
No better subject to ramble on about than sprinkler activation.
I think citing sidewalls under an overhead door is misplaced though
because in that case there is an 'above AND below' setup, and whether
the
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
door is up or down the fire has to be pretty much right under the
'exposed
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
sidewall'. Not so with one compliment.
If you did the back-to-back sidewalls in the middle of the space I
would
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
advocate no wall, baffle, or beam, that being based on some
primitive,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
course modeling I did several years ago looking at activation times
for
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
water curtains with and without a draft stop: with seemed to 1) slow
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
velocity of the ceiling jet a tad and 2) block half the pattern--
RTI is
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
based on temp AND velocity.
I've been modeling this all afternoon in my mind because I skated a
little early today-
I'll actually do it I'm sure, soon, make a youtube movie, and post
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
link to that here-- but, you should resign yourself, re. any real
life
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
application to using a sideWALL essentially with a 'wall' :) ;) :)
B-rad
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Thank you Richard and Brad.
These are some of the exact points I was looking at/for. Up to this
point we had only used them under garage doors. But like Duane
brought up,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
we were wondering if they can be installed under garage doors and be
expected to operate, then shouldn't they also be allowed to be
installed in
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
"exposed" scenarios. Maybe this just one of those "calculated
risks"
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
by
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
the committee if no other testing has been done.
Moving on, so if I follow 8.7.4.1.2.2, and located the deflector
accordingly off the "wall". What are the other defining
characteristics of
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
this "wall"? How deep is it? How long does it have to be? As far
as
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
I
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
know "wall" isn't defined in Chapter 3. You may laugh and think I
am
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
going
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
too far with this, but one of the major sprinkler manufactures
states
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
the
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
following in one of their product listings "Horizontal sidewall
sprinklers
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
are designed for installation along a wall or the side of a beam".
Since
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
they are clearly indicating beams are acceptable for proper
operation,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
can
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
I assume "wall" in 8.7.4.1.2.2 doesn't mean it has to run from
floor to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
ceiling. From this point going forward I can see someone arguing
from
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
(6)
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
different routes, some of which could be considered "educated
guesses".
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
First (2) should be completely acceptable but not preferred, Next
(3)
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
have
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
their pros/cons and varying degrees of applicability, last (1) is
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
most
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
preferred but probably won't be
accepted.
(1) Build a wall.
(2) Install a beam.
(3) Use the definition of Compartment from 3.3.6. A sidewall can be
installed in a "compartment", so an 8" lintel should be sufficient.
Since
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
the 8" lintel allows a maximum opening of 8ft in the wall, space the
heads
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
every 8ft and run the lintel the length of the sidewalls.
(4) Use the definition of Draft Curtain from 8.4.6.4.1. Since this
is
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
acceptable to separate sprinklers with different response times, it
will
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
clearly delay the heat travel long enough for a sprinkler to
operate.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
This
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
would require a barrier 2ft deep running the length of the
sprinklers. No
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
apparent restriction on sprinkler spacing.
(5) Use the definition of Draft Stop from 8.15.4.2. Since this is
acceptable to delay heat traveling vertically from floor to floor.
This
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
would require a barrier 18in deep with heads spaced 6ft apart.
(6) If we decide the wall/beam isn't required to be a heat trap, but
rather a protection of spray from other sprinklers. Use the
definition for
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Baffles with Sidewalls 8.7.3.4. Baffles are at least 8" long, 6"
high, be
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
between 2in and 3in above the deflector, and the bottom be at least
even
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
with the deflector.
Obviously I would like to choose (6) if acceptable. However do you
see
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
any viability of these (4) "educated guesses"?
I appreciate any further input/opinion and of course your time to
listen
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
to me ramble on.
Thanks,
Sean VG
-----Original Message-----
Casterline
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 9:58 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a
wall?
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
*****
Can a horizontal sidewall sprinkler be installed in the center of a
room
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
(flat, smooth clg) provided sprinkler coverage is added behind the
sidewall? In other words, not installed near a wall or soffit.
In reality a sidewall installed 4" to 6" below the ceiling (away
from a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
wall/soffit) should activate in similar fashion as exposed pendents
and
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
uprights (1" - 12" below clg). If code permits "exposed" sidewalls
to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
be
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
installed below roll up doors without soffits, can't an "exposed"
sidewall be installed elsewhere?
Is there anything in the listing of a sidewall that requires the
sprinkler be installed on a wall or soffit? Are there any ROP/ROC
responses from the committee that would help answer the question?
Thoughts?
Duane Johnson, PE
Program Manager
Division of the Fire Marshal (Support Contractor) Office of Research
Services National Institutes of Health
301-496-0487
Duane,
NFPA 13(2007) 8.7.4.1.2 addresses the location of vertical and
horizontal sidewalls in relation to the wall that they are projected
from.
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Sidewall sprinklers cannot be positioned in the center of a room as
a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
pendant.
Dale F. Wingard, SET
Design Manager
Triple "A" Fire Protection, Inc.
251.649.2034
********
Brad
-----Original Message-----
On Behalf Of Richard Carr
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 10:19 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a
wall?
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Under overhead doors is only place I know is acceptable without a
wall.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Sent from my T-Mobile 4G LTE Device
-------- Original message --------
Date: 12/22/2015 11:14 AM (GMT-05:00)
Subject: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
Hi All,
I can't check the forum archives right now because the website isn't
loading for me for some reason. Based on NFPA 13 2013.
Can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
Assuming we meet the all the minimum/maximum spacing requirements,
vertical distance below the deck requirements, standard spray
sprinklers,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
ordinary hazard occupancy, noncombustible construction. Walking
from
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
branchline to branchline left to right, can I install upright,
upright,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
sidewall facing right, sidewall facing left, upright, upright. With
spacing from upright to upright equal to 12ft, spacing from upright
to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
backside of sidewall of 6ft, and spacing from sidewall face to
sidewall
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
face equal to 20ft. Is this acceptable?
The first thing most people say is "will the sidewall be next to
something like a baffle or installed with the pipe in a soffit?"
As of
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
now, no, there is nothing behind the sidewalls. If something is
required,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
please help me find the direction in the code for this requirement
and
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
design parameters.
Because right now all I am finding is a lot of "grey" area that
people
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
can interpret whichever way suits their needs. I'm looking for
"black
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
and
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
white" if it is in there. If it's only "grey", opinions are greatly
appreciated.
Thank you for your time and help!
Thanks,
Sean VG
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
--
Best regards,
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
rongreenman .
2015-12-26 01:25:21 UTC
Permalink
Look in 13/2013 8.15.5.1. Specifically says to use a sidewall in an
elevator pit. Commentary in the Handbook (p. 397) discusses the
justification(s).
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Charles,
True if the elevator car is within 12 inches of the head but, of course,
not when it is any other position. Furthermore, what about the listing of
the sidewall head for a flat, horizontal, smooth ceiling? This certainly
does not describe the bottom of an elevator car.
*Success Through Code Compliance*
*Rahe Loftin, PE *
*Regional Fire Protection Engineer*
*General Services Administration*
*Region 7 - TX, OK, NM, AR, LA*
*Facilities Management & Support 7PMC*
*c - 817-371-3102*
*o - 817-978-7299*
Post by Charles Thurston
Hello Rahe,
Works good when the car is at the bottom of the shaft.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Sidewall heads without a wall is one thing, but what about sidewalls at
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
bottom of elevator shafts that have a wall but no ceiling?
*Success Through Code Compliance*
*Rahe Loftin, PE *
*Regional Fire Protection Engineer*
*General Services Administration*
*Region 7 - TX, OK, NM, AR, LA*
*Facilities Management & Support 7PMC*
*c - 817-371-3102*
*o - 817-978-7299*
On Wed, Dec 23, 2015 at 7:42 PM, Brad Casterline <
Post by Brad Casterline
A few more things Sean then I'll be able to sleep-
1) you're welcome
2) you have put a lot of good thought into this, and thank you for
prompting the ponderance
3) distinct sidewalls back-to-back in the middle of a space without a
baffle or beam to prevent cold soldering is a no go I realize now, but
with
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
a baffle or beam the head on the opposite side of the ignition point
might
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
not activate due to the way the ceiling jet hits the beam, goes under
it,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
and comes back up the other side-- the opposite side spinkler, being
above
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
the bottom and close to the side of the beam leaves it in a "slow and
cold
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
pocket".
The best thing would be a Tyco type back to back attic head, (2
sidewalls
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
with one element) but they would have to bend both deflectors up to
work
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
with a flat ceiling :) unless the ceiling height was up there a ways.
4) seems like you guys there at Aero are really on the ball!!!-- prime
candidates for some serious fire modeling. . .
wbr, Brad
Post by Brad Casterline
*coarse. And an 18" deep draft stop is for containing smoke, not to
enhance sprinkler activation, and, I apologise for not knowing how
to
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
trim
Post by Brad Casterline
threads when at home using my phone.
Post by Brad Casterline
No better subject to ramble on about than sprinkler activation.
I think citing sidewalls under an overhead door is misplaced though
because in that case there is an 'above AND below' setup, and
whether
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
the
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
door is up or down the fire has to be pretty much right under the
'exposed
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
sidewall'. Not so with one compliment.
If you did the back-to-back sidewalls in the middle of the space I
would
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
advocate no wall, baffle, or beam, that being based on some
primitive,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
course modeling I did several years ago looking at activation times
for
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
water curtains with and without a draft stop: with seemed to 1)
slow
Post by Charles Thurston
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
velocity of the ceiling jet a tad and 2) block half the pattern--
RTI is
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
based on temp AND velocity.
I've been modeling this all afternoon in my mind because I skated a
little early today-
I'll actually do it I'm sure, soon, make a youtube movie, and post
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
link to that here-- but, you should resign yourself, re. any real
life
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
application to using a sideWALL essentially with a 'wall' :) ;) :)
B-rad
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Thank you Richard and Brad.
These are some of the exact points I was looking at/for. Up to
this
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
point we had only used them under garage doors. But like Duane
brought up,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
we were wondering if they can be installed under garage doors and
be
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
expected to operate, then shouldn't they also be allowed to be
installed in
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
"exposed" scenarios. Maybe this just one of those "calculated
risks"
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
by
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
the committee if no other testing has been done.
Moving on, so if I follow 8.7.4.1.2.2, and located the deflector
accordingly off the "wall". What are the other defining
characteristics of
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
this "wall"? How deep is it? How long does it have to be? As
far
Post by Charles Thurston
as
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
I
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
know "wall" isn't defined in Chapter 3. You may laugh and think I
am
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
going
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
too far with this, but one of the major sprinkler manufactures
states
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
the
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
following in one of their product listings "Horizontal sidewall
sprinklers
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
are designed for installation along a wall or the side of a beam".
Since
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
they are clearly indicating beams are acceptable for proper
operation,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
can
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
I assume "wall" in 8.7.4.1.2.2 doesn't mean it has to run from
floor to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
ceiling. From this point going forward I can see someone arguing
from
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
(6)
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
different routes, some of which could be considered "educated
guesses".
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
First (2) should be completely acceptable but not preferred, Next
(3)
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
have
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
their pros/cons and varying degrees of applicability, last (1) is
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
most
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
preferred but probably won't be
accepted.
(1) Build a wall.
(2) Install a beam.
(3) Use the definition of Compartment from 3.3.6. A sidewall can
be
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
installed in a "compartment", so an 8" lintel should be
sufficient.
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Since
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
the 8" lintel allows a maximum opening of 8ft in the wall, space
the
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
heads
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
every 8ft and run the lintel the length of the sidewalls.
(4) Use the definition of Draft Curtain from 8.4.6.4.1. Since
this
Post by Charles Thurston
is
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
acceptable to separate sprinklers with different response times,
it
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
will
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
clearly delay the heat travel long enough for a sprinkler to
operate.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
This
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
would require a barrier 2ft deep running the length of the
sprinklers. No
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
apparent restriction on sprinkler spacing.
(5) Use the definition of Draft Stop from 8.15.4.2. Since this is
acceptable to delay heat traveling vertically from floor to floor.
This
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
would require a barrier 18in deep with heads spaced 6ft apart.
(6) If we decide the wall/beam isn't required to be a heat trap,
but
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
rather a protection of spray from other sprinklers. Use the
definition for
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Baffles with Sidewalls 8.7.3.4. Baffles are at least 8" long, 6"
high, be
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
between 2in and 3in above the deflector, and the bottom be at
least
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
even
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
with the deflector.
Obviously I would like to choose (6) if acceptable. However do
you
Post by Charles Thurston
see
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
any viability of these (4) "educated guesses"?
I appreciate any further input/opinion and of course your time to
listen
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
to me ramble on.
Thanks,
Sean VG
-----Original Message-----
Casterline
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 9:58 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a
wall?
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
*****
Can a horizontal sidewall sprinkler be installed in the center of
a
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
room
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
(flat, smooth clg) provided sprinkler coverage is added behind the
sidewall? In other words, not installed near a wall or soffit.
In reality a sidewall installed 4" to 6" below the ceiling (away
from a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
wall/soffit) should activate in similar fashion as exposed
pendents
Post by Charles Thurston
and
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
uprights (1" - 12" below clg). If code permits "exposed"
sidewalls
Post by Charles Thurston
to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
be
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
installed below roll up doors without soffits, can't an "exposed"
sidewall be installed elsewhere?
Is there anything in the listing of a sidewall that requires the
sprinkler be installed on a wall or soffit? Are there any ROP/ROC
responses from the committee that would help answer the question?
Thoughts?
Duane Johnson, PE
Program Manager
Division of the Fire Marshal (Support Contractor) Office of
Research
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Services National Institutes of Health
301-496-0487
Duane,
NFPA 13(2007) 8.7.4.1.2 addresses the location of vertical and
horizontal sidewalls in relation to the wall that they are
projected
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
from.
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Sidewall sprinklers cannot be positioned in the center of a room
as
Post by Charles Thurston
a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
pendant.
Dale F. Wingard, SET
Design Manager
Triple "A" Fire Protection, Inc.
251.649.2034
********
Brad
-----Original Message-----
On Behalf Of Richard Carr
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 10:19 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a
wall?
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Under overhead doors is only place I know is acceptable without a
wall.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Sent from my T-Mobile 4G LTE Device
-------- Original message --------
Date: 12/22/2015 11:14 AM (GMT-05:00)
Subject: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a
wall?
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Hi All,
I can't check the forum archives right now because the website
isn't
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
loading for me for some reason. Based on NFPA 13 2013.
Can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
Assuming we meet the all the minimum/maximum spacing requirements,
vertical distance below the deck requirements, standard spray
sprinklers,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
ordinary hazard occupancy, noncombustible construction. Walking
from
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
branchline to branchline left to right, can I install upright,
upright,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
sidewall facing right, sidewall facing left, upright, upright.
With
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
spacing from upright to upright equal to 12ft, spacing from
upright
Post by Charles Thurston
to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
backside of sidewall of 6ft, and spacing from sidewall face to
sidewall
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
face equal to 20ft. Is this acceptable?
The first thing most people say is "will the sidewall be next to
something like a baffle or installed with the pipe in a soffit?"
As of
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
now, no, there is nothing behind the sidewalls. If something is
required,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
please help me find the direction in the code for this requirement
and
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
design parameters.
Because right now all I am finding is a lot of "grey" area that
people
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
can interpret whichever way suits their needs. I'm looking for
"black
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
and
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
white" if it is in there. If it's only "grey", opinions are
greatly
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
appreciated.
Thank you for your time and help!
Thanks,
Sean VG
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Charles Thurston
--
Best regards,
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
--
Ron Greenman
Instructor
Fire Protection Engineering Technology
Bates Technical College
1101 So. Yakima Ave.
Tacoma, WA 98405

***@bates.ctc.edu

http://www.bates.ctc.edu/fireprotection/

253.680.7346
253.576.9700 (cell)

Member:
ASEE, SFPE, ASCET, NFPA, AFSA, NFSA, AFAA, NIBS, WSAFM, WFC, WFSC

They are happy men whose natures sort with their vocations. -Francis Bacon,
essayist, philosopher, and statesman (1561-1626)

A problem well stated is a problem half solved. -Charles F. Kettering,
inventor and engineer (1876-1958)
Brad Casterline
2015-12-28 10:44:32 UTC
Permalink
What does it say in your words Ron, for those like me whom are too sick
and/or tired to look it up?
Post by rongreenman .
Look in 13/2013 8.15.5.1. Specifically says to use a sidewall in an
elevator pit. Commentary in the Handbook (p. 397) discusses the
justification(s).
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Charles,
True if the elevator car is within 12 inches of the head but, of course,
not when it is any other position. Furthermore, what about the listing of
the sidewall head for a flat, horizontal, smooth ceiling? This certainly
does not describe the bottom of an elevator car.
*Success Through Code Compliance*
*Rahe Loftin, PE *
*Regional Fire Protection Engineer*
*General Services Administration*
*Region 7 - TX, OK, NM, AR, LA*
*Facilities Management & Support 7PMC*
*c - 817-371-3102*
*o - 817-978-7299*
Post by Charles Thurston
Hello Rahe,
Works good when the car is at the bottom of the shaft.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Sidewall heads without a wall is one thing, but what about sidewalls
at
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
bottom of elevator shafts that have a wall but no ceiling?
*Success Through Code Compliance*
*Rahe Loftin, PE *
*Regional Fire Protection Engineer*
*General Services Administration*
*Region 7 - TX, OK, NM, AR, LA*
*Facilities Management & Support 7PMC*
*c - 817-371-3102*
*o - 817-978-7299*
On Wed, Dec 23, 2015 at 7:42 PM, Brad Casterline <
Post by Brad Casterline
A few more things Sean then I'll be able to sleep-
1) you're welcome
2) you have put a lot of good thought into this, and thank you for
prompting the ponderance
3) distinct sidewalls back-to-back in the middle of a space without
a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
baffle or beam to prevent cold soldering is a no go I realize now,
but
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
with
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
a baffle or beam the head on the opposite side of the ignition point
might
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
not activate due to the way the ceiling jet hits the beam, goes
under
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
it,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
and comes back up the other side-- the opposite side spinkler, being
above
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
the bottom and close to the side of the beam leaves it in a "slow
and
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
cold
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
pocket".
The best thing would be a Tyco type back to back attic head, (2
sidewalls
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
with one element) but they would have to bend both deflectors up to
work
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
with a flat ceiling :) unless the ceiling height was up there a
ways.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
4) seems like you guys there at Aero are really on the ball!!!--
prime
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
candidates for some serious fire modeling. . .
wbr, Brad
Post by Brad Casterline
*coarse. And an 18" deep draft stop is for containing smoke, not
to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
enhance sprinkler activation, and, I apologise for not knowing how
to
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
trim
Post by Brad Casterline
threads when at home using my phone.
On Dec 22, 2015 4:48 PM, "Brad Casterline" <
Post by Brad Casterline
No better subject to ramble on about than sprinkler activation.
I think citing sidewalls under an overhead door is misplaced
though
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
because in that case there is an 'above AND below' setup, and
whether
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
the
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
door is up or down the fire has to be pretty much right under the
'exposed
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
sidewall'. Not so with one compliment.
If you did the back-to-back sidewalls in the middle of the space
I
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
would
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
advocate no wall, baffle, or beam, that being based on some
primitive,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
course modeling I did several years ago looking at activation
times
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
for
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
water curtains with and without a draft stop: with seemed to 1)
slow
Post by Charles Thurston
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
velocity of the ceiling jet a tad and 2) block half the pattern--
RTI is
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
based on temp AND velocity.
I've been modeling this all afternoon in my mind because I
skated a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
little early today-
I'll actually do it I'm sure, soon, make a youtube movie, and
post
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
link to that here-- but, you should resign yourself, re. any real
life
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
application to using a sideWALL essentially with a 'wall' :) ;)
:)
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
B-rad
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Thank you Richard and Brad.
These are some of the exact points I was looking at/for. Up to
this
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
point we had only used them under garage doors. But like Duane
brought up,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
we were wondering if they can be installed under garage doors
and
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
be
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
expected to operate, then shouldn't they also be allowed to be
installed in
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
"exposed" scenarios. Maybe this just one of those "calculated
risks"
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
by
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
the committee if no other testing has been done.
Moving on, so if I follow 8.7.4.1.2.2, and located the deflector
accordingly off the "wall". What are the other defining
characteristics of
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
this "wall"? How deep is it? How long does it have to be? As
far
Post by Charles Thurston
as
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
I
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
know "wall" isn't defined in Chapter 3. You may laugh and
think I
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
am
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
going
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
too far with this, but one of the major sprinkler manufactures
states
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
the
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
following in one of their product listings "Horizontal sidewall
sprinklers
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
are designed for installation along a wall or the side of a
beam".
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Since
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
they are clearly indicating beams are acceptable for proper
operation,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
can
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
I assume "wall" in 8.7.4.1.2.2 doesn't mean it has to run from
floor to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
ceiling. From this point going forward I can see someone
arguing
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
from
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
(6)
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
different routes, some of which could be considered "educated
guesses".
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
First (2) should be completely acceptable but not preferred,
Next
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
(3)
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
have
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
their pros/cons and varying degrees of applicability, last (1)
is
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
most
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
preferred but probably won't be
accepted.
(1) Build a wall.
(2) Install a beam.
(3) Use the definition of Compartment from 3.3.6. A sidewall
can
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
be
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
installed in a "compartment", so an 8" lintel should be
sufficient.
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Since
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
the 8" lintel allows a maximum opening of 8ft in the wall, space
the
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
heads
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
every 8ft and run the lintel the length of the sidewalls.
(4) Use the definition of Draft Curtain from 8.4.6.4.1. Since
this
Post by Charles Thurston
is
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
acceptable to separate sprinklers with different response times,
it
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
will
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
clearly delay the heat travel long enough for a sprinkler to
operate.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
This
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
would require a barrier 2ft deep running the length of the
sprinklers. No
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
apparent restriction on sprinkler spacing.
(5) Use the definition of Draft Stop from 8.15.4.2. Since this
is
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
acceptable to delay heat traveling vertically from floor to
floor.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
This
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
would require a barrier 18in deep with heads spaced 6ft apart.
(6) If we decide the wall/beam isn't required to be a heat trap,
but
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
rather a protection of spray from other sprinklers. Use the
definition for
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Baffles with Sidewalls 8.7.3.4. Baffles are at least 8" long,
6"
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
high, be
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
between 2in and 3in above the deflector, and the bottom be at
least
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
even
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
with the deflector.
Obviously I would like to choose (6) if acceptable. However do
you
Post by Charles Thurston
see
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
any viability of these (4) "educated guesses"?
I appreciate any further input/opinion and of course your time
to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
listen
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
to me ramble on.
Thanks,
Sean VG
-----Original Message-----
Brad
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Casterline
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 9:58 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next
to a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
wall?
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
*****
Can a horizontal sidewall sprinkler be installed in the center
of
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
a
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
room
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
(flat, smooth clg) provided sprinkler coverage is added behind
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
sidewall? In other words, not installed near a wall or soffit.
In reality a sidewall installed 4" to 6" below the ceiling (away
from a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
wall/soffit) should activate in similar fashion as exposed
pendents
Post by Charles Thurston
and
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
uprights (1" - 12" below clg). If code permits "exposed"
sidewalls
Post by Charles Thurston
to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
be
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
installed below roll up doors without soffits, can't an
"exposed"
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
sidewall be installed elsewhere?
Is there anything in the listing of a sidewall that requires the
sprinkler be installed on a wall or soffit? Are there any
ROP/ROC
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
responses from the committee that would help answer the
question?
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Thoughts?
Duane Johnson, PE
Program Manager
Division of the Fire Marshal (Support Contractor) Office of
Research
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Services National Institutes of Health
301-496-0487
Duane,
NFPA 13(2007) 8.7.4.1.2 addresses the location of vertical and
horizontal sidewalls in relation to the wall that they are
projected
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
from.
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Sidewall sprinklers cannot be positioned in the center of a room
as
Post by Charles Thurston
a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
pendant.
Dale F. Wingard, SET
Design Manager
Triple "A" Fire Protection, Inc.
251.649.2034
********
Brad
-----Original Message-----
On Behalf Of Richard Carr
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 10:19 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next
to a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
wall?
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Under overhead doors is only place I know is acceptable without
a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
wall.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Sent from my T-Mobile 4G LTE Device
-------- Original message --------
Date: 12/22/2015 11:14 AM (GMT-05:00)
Subject: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a
wall?
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Hi All,
I can't check the forum archives right now because the website
isn't
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
loading for me for some reason. Based on NFPA 13 2013.
Can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
Assuming we meet the all the minimum/maximum spacing
requirements,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
vertical distance below the deck requirements, standard spray
sprinklers,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
ordinary hazard occupancy, noncombustible construction. Walking
from
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
branchline to branchline left to right, can I install upright,
upright,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
sidewall facing right, sidewall facing left, upright, upright.
With
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
spacing from upright to upright equal to 12ft, spacing from
upright
Post by Charles Thurston
to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
backside of sidewall of 6ft, and spacing from sidewall face to
sidewall
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
face equal to 20ft. Is this acceptable?
The first thing most people say is "will the sidewall be next to
something like a baffle or installed with the pipe in a soffit?"
As of
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
now, no, there is nothing behind the sidewalls. If something is
required,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
please help me find the direction in the code for this
requirement
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
and
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
design parameters.
Because right now all I am finding is a lot of "grey" area that
people
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
can interpret whichever way suits their needs. I'm looking for
"black
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
and
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
white" if it is in there. If it's only "grey", opinions are
greatly
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
appreciated.
Thank you for your time and help!
Thanks,
Sean VG
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
--
Best regards,
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
--
Ron Greenman
Instructor
Fire Protection Engineering Technology
Bates Technical College
1101 So. Yakima Ave.
Tacoma, WA 98405
http://www.bates.ctc.edu/fireprotection/
253.680.7346
253.576.9700 (cell)
ASEE, SFPE, ASCET, NFPA, AFSA, NFSA, AFAA, NIBS, WSAFM, WFC, WFSC
They are happy men whose natures sort with their vocations. -Francis Bacon,
essayist, philosopher, and statesman (1561-1626)
A problem well stated is a problem half solved. -Charles F. Kettering,
inventor and engineer (1876-1958)
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
rongreenman .
2016-01-10 22:40:17 UTC
Permalink
Not much interpretation there Brad. Sidewalls no more than two feet off the
floor of all elevator pits. The annex says best under the door opening wall
but to watch out to not interfere with the toe guard. Awfully clear. Then
go to 8.15.5.2 and it sys you can ignore 8.15.5.1 if there is no hydraulic
fluid. Again clear. Cable hoists nothing in the pit. Hydraulic elevators
(presuming the the lifting mechanism is in the pit, which it always is)
require them I could care less about listings or hazards classifications
here. This is a unique space that is clearly addressed in the standard.
Remember that since the standard went ISO their can be no lists of
exceptions, only positive directions that say what you shall do, not what
you don't have to do.
Post by Brad Casterline
What does it say in your words Ron, for those like me whom are too sick
and/or tired to look it up?
Post by rongreenman .
Look in 13/2013 8.15.5.1. Specifically says to use a sidewall in an
elevator pit. Commentary in the Handbook (p. 397) discusses the
justification(s).
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Charles,
True if the elevator car is within 12 inches of the head but, of
course,
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
not when it is any other position. Furthermore, what about the listing
of
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
the sidewall head for a flat, horizontal, smooth ceiling? This
certainly
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
does not describe the bottom of an elevator car.
*Success Through Code Compliance*
*Rahe Loftin, PE *
*Regional Fire Protection Engineer*
*General Services Administration*
*Region 7 - TX, OK, NM, AR, LA*
*Facilities Management & Support 7PMC*
*c - 817-371-3102*
*o - 817-978-7299*
Post by Charles Thurston
Hello Rahe,
Works good when the car is at the bottom of the shaft.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Sidewall heads without a wall is one thing, but what about
sidewalls
Post by rongreenman .
at
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
bottom of elevator shafts that have a wall but no ceiling?
*Success Through Code Compliance*
*Rahe Loftin, PE *
*Regional Fire Protection Engineer*
*General Services Administration*
*Region 7 - TX, OK, NM, AR, LA*
*Facilities Management & Support 7PMC*
*c - 817-371-3102*
*o - 817-978-7299*
On Wed, Dec 23, 2015 at 7:42 PM, Brad Casterline <
Post by Brad Casterline
A few more things Sean then I'll be able to sleep-
1) you're welcome
2) you have put a lot of good thought into this, and thank you for
prompting the ponderance
3) distinct sidewalls back-to-back in the middle of a space
without
Post by rongreenman .
a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
baffle or beam to prevent cold soldering is a no go I realize now,
but
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
with
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
a baffle or beam the head on the opposite side of the ignition
point
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
might
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
not activate due to the way the ceiling jet hits the beam, goes
under
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
it,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
and comes back up the other side-- the opposite side spinkler,
being
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
above
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
the bottom and close to the side of the beam leaves it in a "slow
and
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
cold
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
pocket".
The best thing would be a Tyco type back to back attic head, (2
sidewalls
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
with one element) but they would have to bend both deflectors up
to
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
work
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
with a flat ceiling :) unless the ceiling height was up there a
ways.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
4) seems like you guys there at Aero are really on the ball!!!--
prime
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
candidates for some serious fire modeling. . .
wbr, Brad
On Dec 22, 2015 5:05 PM, "Brad Casterline" <
Post by Brad Casterline
*coarse. And an 18" deep draft stop is for containing smoke, not
to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
enhance sprinkler activation, and, I apologise for not knowing
how
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
to
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
trim
Post by Brad Casterline
threads when at home using my phone.
On Dec 22, 2015 4:48 PM, "Brad Casterline" <
Post by Brad Casterline
No better subject to ramble on about than sprinkler activation.
I think citing sidewalls under an overhead door is misplaced
though
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
because in that case there is an 'above AND below' setup, and
whether
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
the
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
door is up or down the fire has to be pretty much right under
the
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
'exposed
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
sidewall'. Not so with one compliment.
If you did the back-to-back sidewalls in the middle of the
space
Post by rongreenman .
I
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
would
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
advocate no wall, baffle, or beam, that being based on some
primitive,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
course modeling I did several years ago looking at activation
times
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
for
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
water curtains with and without a draft stop: with seemed to 1)
slow
Post by Charles Thurston
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
velocity of the ceiling jet a tad and 2) block half the
pattern--
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
RTI is
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
based on temp AND velocity.
I've been modeling this all afternoon in my mind because I
skated a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
little early today-
I'll actually do it I'm sure, soon, make a youtube movie, and
post
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
link to that here-- but, you should resign yourself, re. any
real
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
life
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
application to using a sideWALL essentially with a 'wall' :)
;)
Post by rongreenman .
:)
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
B-rad
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Thank you Richard and Brad.
These are some of the exact points I was looking at/for. Up
to
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
this
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
point we had only used them under garage doors. But like
Duane
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
brought up,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
we were wondering if they can be installed under garage doors
and
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
be
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
expected to operate, then shouldn't they also be allowed to be
installed in
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
"exposed" scenarios. Maybe this just one of those "calculated
risks"
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
by
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
the committee if no other testing has been done.
Moving on, so if I follow 8.7.4.1.2.2, and located the
deflector
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
accordingly off the "wall". What are the other defining
characteristics of
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
this "wall"? How deep is it? How long does it have to be?
As
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
far
Post by Charles Thurston
as
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
I
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
know "wall" isn't defined in Chapter 3. You may laugh and
think I
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
am
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
going
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
too far with this, but one of the major sprinkler manufactures
states
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
the
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
following in one of their product listings "Horizontal
sidewall
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
sprinklers
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
are designed for installation along a wall or the side of a
beam".
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Since
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
they are clearly indicating beams are acceptable for proper
operation,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
can
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
I assume "wall" in 8.7.4.1.2.2 doesn't mean it has to run from
floor to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
ceiling. From this point going forward I can see someone
arguing
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
from
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
(6)
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
different routes, some of which could be considered "educated
guesses".
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
First (2) should be completely acceptable but not preferred,
Next
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
(3)
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
have
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
their pros/cons and varying degrees of applicability, last (1)
is
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
most
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
preferred but probably won't be
accepted.
(1) Build a wall.
(2) Install a beam.
(3) Use the definition of Compartment from 3.3.6. A sidewall
can
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
be
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
installed in a "compartment", so an 8" lintel should be
sufficient.
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Since
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
the 8" lintel allows a maximum opening of 8ft in the wall,
space
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
the
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
heads
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
every 8ft and run the lintel the length of the sidewalls.
(4) Use the definition of Draft Curtain from 8.4.6.4.1. Since
this
Post by Charles Thurston
is
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
acceptable to separate sprinklers with different response
times,
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
it
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
will
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
clearly delay the heat travel long enough for a sprinkler to
operate.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
This
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
would require a barrier 2ft deep running the length of the
sprinklers. No
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
apparent restriction on sprinkler spacing.
(5) Use the definition of Draft Stop from 8.15.4.2. Since
this
Post by rongreenman .
is
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
acceptable to delay heat traveling vertically from floor to
floor.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
This
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
would require a barrier 18in deep with heads spaced 6ft apart.
(6) If we decide the wall/beam isn't required to be a heat
trap,
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
but
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
rather a protection of spray from other sprinklers. Use the
definition for
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Baffles with Sidewalls 8.7.3.4. Baffles are at least 8" long,
6"
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
high, be
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
between 2in and 3in above the deflector, and the bottom be at
least
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
even
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
with the deflector.
Obviously I would like to choose (6) if acceptable. However
do
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
you
Post by Charles Thurston
see
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
any viability of these (4) "educated guesses"?
I appreciate any further input/opinion and of course your time
to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
listen
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
to me ramble on.
Thanks,
Sean VG
-----Original Message-----
Brad
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Casterline
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 9:58 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next
to a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
wall?
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
*****
Can a horizontal sidewall sprinkler be installed in the center
of
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
a
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
room
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
(flat, smooth clg) provided sprinkler coverage is added behind
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
sidewall? In other words, not installed near a wall or
soffit.
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
In reality a sidewall installed 4" to 6" below the ceiling
(away
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
from a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
wall/soffit) should activate in similar fashion as exposed
pendents
Post by Charles Thurston
and
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
uprights (1" - 12" below clg). If code permits "exposed"
sidewalls
Post by Charles Thurston
to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
be
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
installed below roll up doors without soffits, can't an
"exposed"
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
sidewall be installed elsewhere?
Is there anything in the listing of a sidewall that requires
the
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
sprinkler be installed on a wall or soffit? Are there any
ROP/ROC
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
responses from the committee that would help answer the
question?
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Thoughts?
Duane Johnson, PE
Program Manager
Division of the Fire Marshal (Support Contractor) Office of
Research
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Services National Institutes of Health
301-496-0487
Duane,
NFPA 13(2007) 8.7.4.1.2 addresses the location of vertical and
horizontal sidewalls in relation to the wall that they are
projected
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
from.
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Sidewall sprinklers cannot be positioned in the center of a
room
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
as
Post by Charles Thurston
a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
pendant.
Dale F. Wingard, SET
Design Manager
Triple "A" Fire Protection, Inc.
251.649.2034
********
Brad
-----Original Message-----
On Behalf Of Richard Carr
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 10:19 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located next
to a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
wall?
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Under overhead doors is only place I know is acceptable
without
Post by rongreenman .
a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
wall.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Sent from my T-Mobile 4G LTE Device
-------- Original message --------
Date: 12/22/2015 11:14 AM (GMT-05:00)
Subject: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a
wall?
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Hi All,
I can't check the forum archives right now because the website
isn't
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
loading for me for some reason. Based on NFPA 13 2013.
Can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
Assuming we meet the all the minimum/maximum spacing
requirements,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
vertical distance below the deck requirements, standard spray
sprinklers,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
ordinary hazard occupancy, noncombustible construction.
Walking
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
from
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
branchline to branchline left to right, can I install upright,
upright,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
sidewall facing right, sidewall facing left, upright, upright.
With
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
spacing from upright to upright equal to 12ft, spacing from
upright
Post by Charles Thurston
to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
backside of sidewall of 6ft, and spacing from sidewall face to
sidewall
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
face equal to 20ft. Is this acceptable?
The first thing most people say is "will the sidewall be next
to
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
something like a baffle or installed with the pipe in a
soffit?"
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
As of
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
now, no, there is nothing behind the sidewalls. If something
is
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
required,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
please help me find the direction in the code for this
requirement
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
and
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
design parameters.
Because right now all I am finding is a lot of "grey" area
that
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
people
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
can interpret whichever way suits their needs. I'm looking
for
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
"black
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
and
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
white" if it is in there. If it's only "grey", opinions are
greatly
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
appreciated.
Thank you for your time and help!
Thanks,
Sean VG
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
--
Best regards,
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
Post by rongreenman .
--
Ron Greenman
Instructor
Fire Protection Engineering Technology
Bates Technical College
1101 So. Yakima Ave.
Tacoma, WA 98405
http://www.bates.ctc.edu/fireprotection/
253.680.7346
253.576.9700 (cell)
ASEE, SFPE, ASCET, NFPA, AFSA, NFSA, AFAA, NIBS, WSAFM, WFC, WFSC
They are happy men whose natures sort with their vocations. -Francis
Bacon,
Post by rongreenman .
essayist, philosopher, and statesman (1561-1626)
A problem well stated is a problem half solved. -Charles F. Kettering,
inventor and engineer (1876-1958)
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkler.org
--
Ron Greenman
Instructor
Fire Protection Engineering Technology
Bates Technical College
1101 So. Yakima Ave.
Tacoma, WA 98405

***@bates.ctc.edu

http://www.bates.ctc.edu/fireprotection/

253.680.7346
253.576.9700 (cell)

Member:
ASEE, SFPE, ASCET, NFPA, AFSA, NFSA, AFAA, NIBS, WSAFM, WFC, WFSC

They are happy men whose natures sort with their vocations. -Francis Bacon,
essayist, philosopher, and statesman (1561-1626)

A problem well stated is a problem half solved. -Charles F. Kettering,
inventor and engineer (1876-1958)
Brad Casterline
2016-01-11 14:37:56 UTC
Permalink
Thanks Ron.

The commentary on pg. 396 is interesting also.
I found this link, which is a NIST compilation of elevator/fire research:

http://www.nist.gov/el/disasterstudies/wtc/elevator_publications.cfm

I looked at 'Elevators and Sprinklers' and it appears to be where a lot of
the current requirements came from.

Brad

-----Original Message-----
From: Sprinklerforum [mailto:sprinklerforum-***@lists.firesprinkler.org]
On Behalf Of rongreenman .
Sent: Sunday, January 10, 2016 4:40 PM
To: ***@lists.firesprinkler.org
Subject: Re: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?

Not much interpretation there Brad. Sidewalls no more than two feet off the
floor of all elevator pits. The annex says best under the door opening wall
but to watch out to not interfere with the toe guard. Awfully clear. Then
go to 8.15.5.2 and it sys you can ignore 8.15.5.1 if there is no hydraulic
fluid. Again clear. Cable hoists nothing in the pit. Hydraulic elevators
(presuming the the lifting mechanism is in the pit, which it always is)
require them I could care less about listings or hazards classifications
here. This is a unique space that is clearly addressed in the standard.
Remember that since the standard went ISO their can be no lists of
exceptions, only positive directions that say what you shall do, not what
you don't have to do.
--
Ron Greenman
Instructor
Fire Protection Engineering Technology
Bates Technical College
1101 So. Yakima Ave.
Tacoma, WA 98405

***@bates.ctc.edu

http://www.bates.ctc.edu/fireprotection/

253.680.7346
253.576.9700 (cell)

Member:
ASEE, SFPE, ASCET, NFPA, AFSA, NFSA, AFAA, NIBS, WSAFM, WFC, WFSC

They are happy men whose natures sort with their vocations. -Francis Bacon,
essayist, philosopher, and statesman (1561-1626)

A problem well stated is a problem half solved. -Charles F. Kettering,
inventor and engineer (1876-1958)
Frank Herrick
2016-01-12 17:46:22 UTC
Permalink
Sidewall type sprinkler heads are very commonly used for coverage under garage doors, when in the open position.



Captain Frank J. Herrick
City Of Leawood Fire Department
14801 Mission Road
Leawood, KS. 66224-9560
Office: 913.266.0608
Fax: 913.681.2399
Cell: 913.238.6942
Fire Sprinklers Save Lives, Property, the Environment, and Water - Protect what you value most!








-----Original Message-----
From: rongreenman . [mailto:***@gmail.com]
Sent: Sunday, January 10, 2016 4:40 PM
To: ***@lists.firesprinkler.org
Subject: Re: can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?



Not much interpretation there Brad. Sidewalls no more than two feet off the floor of all elevator pits. The annex says best under the door opening wall but to watch out to not interfere with the toe guard. Awfully clear. Then go to 8.15.5.2 and it sys you can ignore 8.15.5.1 if there is no hydraulic fluid. Again clear. Cable hoists nothing in the pit. Hydraulic elevators (presuming the the lifting mechanism is in the pit, which it always is) require them I could care less about listings or hazards classifications here. This is a unique space that is clearly addressed in the standard.

Remember that since the standard went ISO their can be no lists of exceptions, only positive directions that say what you shall do, not what you don't have to do.
Post by Brad Casterline
What does it say in your words Ron, for those like me whom are too
sick and/or tired to look it up?
Post by rongreenman .
Look in 13/2013 8.15.5.1. Specifically says to use a sidewall in an
elevator pit. Commentary in the Handbook (p. 397) discusses the
justification(s).
On Fri, Dec 25, 2015 at 3:30 PM, Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Charles,
True if the elevator car is within 12 inches of the head but, of
course,
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
not when it is any other position. Furthermore, what about the
listing
of
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
the sidewall head for a flat, horizontal, smooth ceiling? This
certainly
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
does not describe the bottom of an elevator car.
*Success Through Code Compliance*
*Rahe Loftin, PE *
*Regional Fire Protection Engineer* *General Services
Administration* *Region 7 - TX, OK, NM, AR, LA* *Facilities
Management & Support 7PMC* *c - 817-371-3102* *o - 817-978-7299*
On Fri, Dec 25, 2015 at 7:37 AM, Charles Thurston
Post by Charles Thurston
Hello Rahe,
Works good when the car is at the bottom of the shaft.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Sidewall heads without a wall is one thing, but what about
sidewalls
Post by rongreenman .
at
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
bottom of elevator shafts that have a wall but no ceiling?
*Success Through Code Compliance*
*Rahe Loftin, PE *
*Regional Fire Protection Engineer* *General Services
Administration* *Region 7 - TX, OK, NM, AR, LA* *Facilities
Management & Support 7PMC* *c - 817-371-3102* *o -
817-978-7299*
On Wed, Dec 23, 2015 at 7:42 PM, Brad Casterline <
Post by Brad Casterline
A few more things Sean then I'll be able to sleep-
1) you're welcome
2) you have put a lot of good thought into this, and thank
you for prompting the ponderance
3) distinct sidewalls back-to-back in the middle of a space
without
Post by rongreenman .
a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
baffle or beam to prevent cold soldering is a no go I realize
now,
but
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
with
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
a baffle or beam the head on the opposite side of the
ignition
point
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
might
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
not activate due to the way the ceiling jet hits the beam,
goes
under
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
it,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
and comes back up the other side-- the opposite side
spinkler,
being
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
above
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
the bottom and close to the side of the beam leaves it in a
"slow
and
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
cold
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
pocket".
The best thing would be a Tyco type back to back attic head,
(2
sidewalls
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
with one element) but they would have to bend both deflectors
up
to
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
work
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
with a flat ceiling :) unless the ceiling height was up there
a
ways.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
4) seems like you guys there at Aero are really on the
ball!!!--
prime
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
candidates for some serious fire modeling. . .
wbr, Brad
On Dec 22, 2015 5:05 PM, "Brad Casterline" <
Post by Brad Casterline
*coarse. And an 18" deep draft stop is for containing
smoke, not
to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
enhance sprinkler activation, and, I apologise for not
knowing
how
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
to
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
trim
Post by Brad Casterline
threads when at home using my phone.
On Dec 22, 2015 4:48 PM, "Brad Casterline" <
Post by Brad Casterline
No better subject to ramble on about than sprinkler activation.
I think citing sidewalls under an overhead door is
misplaced
though
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
because in that case there is an 'above AND below' setup,
and
whether
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
the
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
door is up or down the fire has to be pretty much right
under
the
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
'exposed
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
sidewall'. Not so with one compliment.
If you did the back-to-back sidewalls in the middle of the
space
Post by rongreenman .
I
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
would
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
advocate no wall, baffle, or beam, that being based on
some
primitive,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
course modeling I did several years ago looking at
activation
times
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
for
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
water curtains with and without a draft stop: with seemed
to 1)
slow
Post by Charles Thurston
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
velocity of the ceiling jet a tad and 2) block half the
pattern--
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
RTI is
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
based on temp AND velocity.
I've been modeling this all afternoon in my mind because I
skated a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
little early today-
I'll actually do it I'm sure, soon, make a youtube movie,
and
post
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
link to that here-- but, you should resign yourself, re.
any
real
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
life
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
application to using a sideWALL essentially with a 'wall'
:)
;)
Post by rongreenman .
:)
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
B-rad
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Thank you Richard and Brad.
These are some of the exact points I was looking at/for.
Up
to
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
this
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
point we had only used them under garage doors. But like
Duane
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
brought up,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
we were wondering if they can be installed under garage
doors
and
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
be
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
expected to operate, then shouldn't they also be allowed
to be
installed in
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
"exposed" scenarios. Maybe this just one of those
"calculated
risks"
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
by
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
the committee if no other testing has been done.
Moving on, so if I follow 8.7.4.1.2.2, and located the
deflector
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
accordingly off the "wall". What are the other defining
characteristics of
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
this "wall"? How deep is it? How long does it have to be?
As
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
far
Post by Charles Thurston
as
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
I
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
know "wall" isn't defined in Chapter 3. You may laugh
and
think I
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
am
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
going
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
too far with this, but one of the major sprinkler
manufactures
states
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
the
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
following in one of their product listings "Horizontal
sidewall
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
sprinklers
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
are designed for installation along a wall or the side of
a
beam".
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Since
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
they are clearly indicating beams are acceptable for
proper
operation,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
can
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
I assume "wall" in 8.7.4.1.2.2 doesn't mean it has to run
from
floor to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
ceiling. From this point going forward I can see someone
arguing
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
from
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
(6)
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
different routes, some of which could be considered
"educated
guesses".
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
First (2) should be completely acceptable but not
preferred,
Next
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
(3)
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
have
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
their pros/cons and varying degrees of applicability,
last (1)
is
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
most
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
preferred but probably won't be accepted.
(1) Build a wall.
(2) Install a beam.
(3) Use the definition of Compartment from 3.3.6. A
sidewall
can
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
be
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
installed in a "compartment", so an 8" lintel should be
sufficient.
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Since
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
the 8" lintel allows a maximum opening of 8ft in the
wall,
space
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
the
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
heads
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
every 8ft and run the lintel the length of the sidewalls.
(4) Use the definition of Draft Curtain from 8.4.6.4.1.
Since
this
Post by Charles Thurston
is
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
acceptable to separate sprinklers with different response
times,
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
it
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
will
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
clearly delay the heat travel long enough for a sprinkler
to
operate.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
This
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
would require a barrier 2ft deep running the length of
the
sprinklers. No
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
apparent restriction on sprinkler spacing.
(5) Use the definition of Draft Stop from 8.15.4.2.
Since
this
Post by rongreenman .
is
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
acceptable to delay heat traveling vertically from floor
to
floor.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
This
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
would require a barrier 18in deep with heads spaced 6ft apart.
(6) If we decide the wall/beam isn't required to be a
heat
trap,
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
but
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
rather a protection of spray from other sprinklers. Use
the
definition for
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Baffles with Sidewalls 8.7.3.4. Baffles are at least 8"
long,
6"
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
high, be
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
between 2in and 3in above the deflector, and the bottom
be at
least
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
even
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
with the deflector.
Obviously I would like to choose (6) if acceptable.
However
do
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
you
Post by Charles Thurston
see
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
any viability of these (4) "educated guesses"?
I appreciate any further input/opinion and of course your
time
to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
listen
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
to me ramble on.
Thanks,
Sean VG
-----Original Message-----
Of
Brad
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Casterline
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 9:58 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located
next
to a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
wall?
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
*****
Can a horizontal sidewall sprinkler be installed in the
center
of
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
a
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
room
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
(flat, smooth clg) provided sprinkler coverage is added
behind
the
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
sidewall? In other words, not installed near a wall or
soffit.
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
In reality a sidewall installed 4" to 6" below the
ceiling
(away
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
from a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
wall/soffit) should activate in similar fashion as
exposed
pendents
Post by Charles Thurston
and
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
uprights (1" - 12" below clg). If code permits "exposed"
sidewalls
Post by Charles Thurston
to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
be
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
installed below roll up doors without soffits, can't an
"exposed"
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
sidewall be installed elsewhere?
Is there anything in the listing of a sidewall that
requires
the
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
sprinkler be installed on a wall or soffit? Are there
any
ROP/ROC
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
responses from the committee that would help answer the
question?
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Thoughts?
Duane Johnson, PE
Program Manager
Division of the Fire Marshal (Support Contractor) Office
of
Research
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Services National Institutes of Health
301-496-0487
Duane,
NFPA 13(2007) 8.7.4.1.2 addresses the location of
vertical and horizontal sidewalls in relation to the wall
that they are
projected
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
from.
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Sidewall sprinklers cannot be positioned in the center of
a
room
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
as
Post by Charles Thurston
a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
pendant.
Dale F. Wingard, SET
Design Manager
Triple "A" Fire Protection, Inc.
251.649.2034
********
Brad
-----Original Message-----
On Behalf Of Richard Carr
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2015 10:19 AM
Subject: RE: can sidewalls be installed when not located
next
to a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
wall?
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Under overhead doors is only place I know is acceptable
without
Post by rongreenman .
a
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
wall.
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Sent from my T-Mobile 4G LTE Device
-------- Original message --------
Date: 12/22/2015 11:14 AM (GMT-05:00)
Subject: can sidewalls be installed when not located next
to a
wall?
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
Hi All,
I can't check the forum archives right now because the
website
isn't
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
loading for me for some reason. Based on NFPA 13 2013.
Can sidewalls be installed when not located next to a wall?
Assuming we meet the all the minimum/maximum spacing
requirements,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
vertical distance below the deck requirements, standard
spray
sprinklers,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
ordinary hazard occupancy, noncombustible construction.
Walking
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
from
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
branchline to branchline left to right, can I install
upright,
upright,
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
sidewall facing right, sidewall facing left, upright, upright.
With
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
spacing from upright to upright equal to 12ft, spacing
from
upright
Post by Charles Thurston
to
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
backside of sidewall of 6ft, and spacing from sidewall
face to
sidewall
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
face equal to 20ft. Is this acceptable?
The first thing most people say is "will the sidewall be
next
to
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
something like a baffle or installed with the pipe in a
soffit?"
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
As of
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
now, no, there is nothing behind the sidewalls. If
something
is
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
required,
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
please help me find the direction in the code for this
requirement
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
and
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
design parameters.
Because right now all I am finding is a lot of "grey"
area
that
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
people
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
can interpret whichever way suits their needs. I'm
looking
for
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
"black
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
and
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
white" if it is in there. If it's only "grey", opinions
are
greatly
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
appreciated.
Thank you for your time and help!
Thanks,
Sean VG
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkl
er.org
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkl
er.org
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkl
er.org
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by Brad Casterline
Post by S***@aerofire.com
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkl
er.org
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Brad Casterline
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkl
er.org
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkl
er.org
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
Post by Charles Thurston
--
Best regards,
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkl
er.org
Post by rongreenman .
Post by Rahe Loftin - 7PMC
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkl
er.org
Post by rongreenman .
--
Ron Greenman
Instructor
Fire Protection Engineering Technology Bates Technical College
1101 So. Yakima Ave.
Tacoma, WA 98405
http://www.bates.ctc.edu/fireprotection/
253.680.7346
253.576.9700 (cell)
ASEE, SFPE, ASCET, NFPA, AFSA, NFSA, AFAA, NIBS, WSAFM, WFC, WFSC
They are happy men whose natures sort with their vocations. -Francis
Bacon,
Post by rongreenman .
essayist, philosopher, and statesman (1561-1626)
A problem well stated is a problem half solved. -Charles F.
Kettering, inventor and engineer (1876-1958)
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkl
er.org
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/listinfo.cgi/sprinklerforum-firesprinkl
er.org
--

Ron Greenman

Instructor

Fire Protection Engineering Technology

Bates Technical College

1101 So. Yakima Ave.

Tacoma, WA 98405



***@bates.ctc.edu<mailto:***@bates.ctc.edu>



http://www.bates.ctc.edu/fireprotection/



253.680.7346

253.576.9700 (cell)



Member:

ASEE, SFPE, ASCET, NFPA, AFSA, NFSA, AFAA, NIBS, WSAFM, WFC, WFSC



They are happy men whose natures sort with their vocations. -Francis Bacon, essayist, philosopher, and statesman (1561-1626)



A problem well stated is a problem half solved. -Charles F. Kettering, inventor and engineer (1876-1958)
Continue reading on narkive:
Loading...